|
How to give a good talk
I am constantly surprised at just how bad most conference, colloquium
and job talks are. I am even more surprised that many speakers make
the same, preventable, mistakes. Here I enumerate what I consider to
be some of the most important things that you can do to give a good
talk.
-
Don't overwhelm your audience. It is better to clearly
explain one or two main ideas than to cursorily cover four or
five ideas. In a one hour talk, your audience can only absorb
one or two central ideas - if you try to cover several years
worth of work, they are going to be overwhelmed and will stop
paying attention. Decide what you think are the one or two most
important ideas in your work and present them clearly. At the
end of your talk you can briefly discuss other aspects of your
work, and refer interested individuals to your papers.
-
Talks are different from papers. While you must
explain the details of your work in a paper, this is not
necessary in a talk. The primary goal of a talk is not to
explain every detail of your work. It is preferable to leave out
particularly complicated or notationally heavy details that are
not critical to the understanding of the basic concepts. It is
more important to explain the general concepts, build intuition,
and then allow those that are interested to read your papers to
get all of the details.
-
Structure. Your talk should consist of the following
components: (1) introduce the problem that you are working on
(for a specialized audience, this can be very brief); (2) explain
why this is an interesting or important problem (again, brief if
your audience are specialists in your area); (3) describe what
previous work has told us about this problem; (4) describe the
specific problem that you are going to solve; (5) explain how you
solved this problem; (6) explain how your work pushes forward our
thinking or understanding; (7) discuss what, if anything, are the
remaining open problems. By the way, I think that "outline"
slides at the beginning of a talk are silly - they all are
exactly the same and are a waste of time.
-
Be gracious and honest. When talking about the work of
others, be gracious. When talking about your own work be honest.
Be particularly honest about any weaknesses or shortcomings in
your work - if your audience senses that you are not being
honest, they can become aggressive and confrontational.
-
Simplify your slides.
-
Minimize the amount of text on each slide. If you have
too much text on your slides, then you create a conflict for
your audience - should they listen to you or should they
read? They will, most likely, read and ignore what you are
saying. Whenever possible use a picture or figure instead
of words.
-
Minimize the amount of information on each slide. A good
slide contains a simple figure, graph, or equation.
-
Minimize the amount of mathematical notation. Your
audience cannot hold onto too much new notation, so try to
minimize notational complexity or remind your audience every
once in a while about the notation.
-
Be consistent with font size, notation, and style. Don't
get fancy with colors, fonts or backgrounds (they are
distracting) - black text on a white background, and color
only when you need to emphasize something.
-
If you use PowerPoint, try to break free of the templates
provided by this software - they are ugly and lead to
text-heavy slides. And, do not use any of the PowerPoint
features such as sound-effects or fade-ins - they are
silly and distracting.
-
Explain your slides. For a graph, explain the axes,
and what is being plotted. For an equation, walk through it
carefully explaining the variables and any special notation. For
a figure, explain the various components. When describing
specific things on your slide, walk to the front of the screen,
if possible, and point at your slides (with your hand).
-
Speaking Speak clearly and loud enough to be heard at
the back of the room. Don't stare at your shoes or slides while
you are talking. Your talk is a chance for you to share with your
audience work that, I presume, you are excited about. Don't force
any particular style onto yourself, but do try to stay relaxed
and have fun.
-
Opening & closing lines. The beginning and end of a
talk are, in some ways, the most difficult. Memorize the first
two and the last two sentences. Do not, however, memorize or
read your talk. It is intensely boring and difficult for your
audience to follow when being read to. And, don't ever start
with a joke - in fact, don't tell jokes, they usually aren't
funny.
-
Practice, practice, practice. Your first practice talk
will be terrible, your second one will be less terrible, your
third practice talk will be acceptable, and, if you are lucky,
your fourth practice talk will be good. You should give at least
one of these practice talks to colleagues that don't know your
work very well, thus simulating your eventual audience.
-
Time your talk. A conference talk is fairly easy to
time because at most conferences, questions are held to the very
end. If you are allotted 30 minutes for your talk, you should
leave 5 minutes at the end for questions. You absolutely should
not run late. For a colloquium or job talk, it is more difficult
to predict the timing, since you may or may not be interrupted
with questions. To accommodate this variability, your talk should
be somewhat fluid where, if you are running late, there are a
series of slides that you can skip over, without disrupting the
logic of your talk. If you are running late, do not try to cram
in the last few slides by talking very fast - simply say "as
time is short, I will skip over this part. For those interested,
please come talk with me afterwards".
-
Laser pointers. Do not use laser pointers, unless
absolutely necessary. If you do use one, put it down when you
are not using it, otherwise you will wave it around in a
meaningless and annoying way.
-
Listen to the question. Listen carefully to what is
being asked - do not try to formulate an answer until you are
sure that you understand the question. If you are unsure of the
question, repeat the question to make sure that you understood it
correctly (this also gives you some extra time to think of an
answer). At a conference it is often difficult to hear the
question at the back of the room, so repeat a condensed version
of the question for those that didn't hear.
-
I don't know. If you do not know the answer to a
question, simply say "I don't know" or "I'm not sure" - this can
be followed-up with something that you think might speak to the
question. This is far more preferable than trying to scramble
for an answer and saying something incoherent.
-
Thank you. Say "thank you" at the end of your talk so
that the audience knows that you are done and that they should
applaud.
|